Every wedding is unique, which is why we offer a variety of dessert options. From traditional wedding cakes to creative alternatives we allow couples to save without sacrificing style or quality.
Whether you're envisioning a classic cake cutting moment or a modern dessert experience, we'll help you choose the option that fits your guest count, vision, and budget.
Wedding Cakes
Our wedding cakes are made from scratch and customized to reflect your wedding style, flavor preferences, and overall aesthetic.
Available Options Include:
Cutting Cakes
Single Tier Cakes
Tiered Cakes
Sheet Cakes
Wedding cake pricing varies based on size, number of tiers, and design complexity. See below for base pricing.
Not sure on Flavors? Schedule a tasting.
Choosing flavors should be fun, not stressful. We offer tasting boxes for couples who want to sample cake and dessert options before making final decisions.
Tasting boxes may include:
• Cake slices
• Cheesecake cups
• Mini cake cups
• Cupcakes
• Select specialty desserts
​
Tastings are available by appointment and are credited toward your final wedding order. Tasting boxes range from $35-$60 depending on what you would like included.
Cocktail Hour/Late Night Snacking
Keep guests satisfied during cocktail hour with bite-sized sweets and snackabe treats that are easy to enjoy while mingling.
$3.00 per guest (50 guest minimum)​
Pick 2-3 options like:
-
Mini Milk + Cookie Shooters
-
Cinnamon Roll Pops
-
Cheesecake Cups
-
Mini Cupcakes
-
Fruit Tartlets
-
Macarons
-
Cake Cups
-
Cake Pops
-
Brownie Bites
-
Mini S'mores
-
Hand Pies
Classic Sweet Table Packages
A mix of timeless desserts designed to serve guests efficiently while maintaining visual appeal.
Intimate Celebration
Serves approx. 50 guests
Includes:
• 8" cutting cake
• Cupcakes
• Cake pops
• Chocolate-covered pretzels
• Chocolate-covered Oreos
• Rice Krispie treats
Starting at $275
Signature Celebration
Serves approx. 100 guests
Includes:
• Custom 8" single-tier cake
• Expanded selection of classic desserts to accommodate higher guest count
Starting at $350
Grand Celebration
Serves approx. 150+ guests
Includes:
• Tiered cake or larger cutting cake
• Full classic sweets table, including:
-
Cupcakes
-
Cake pops
-
Chocolate-covered pretzels
-
Chocolate-covered Oreos
-
Rice Krispie treats
Starting at $600
Signature Dessert Table Packages
An elevated dessert experience featuring a mix of classic and premium desserts.
Signature Luxe
Serves approx. 75 guests
Includes:
• 8" custom cake or cutting cake
• Cheesecake cups
• Mini cake cups
• Cupcakes
• Classic desserts
Starting at $375
Grand Luxe
Serves approx. 125 guests
Includes:
• Large custom cake or tiered cake
• Cheesecake cups
• Mini cake cups
• Macarons
• Cupcakes
• Classic desserts
Starting at $625
Showstopper Display Cake (Faux Cake Option)
For couples who love the look of a grand cake but want a more budget-friendly serving option, we offer faux display cakes paired with real sheet cake.
Includes:
-
Faux tiered display cake (rental)
-
Real cake for cutting
-
Sheet cake to serve guests
-
Click here for sheet cake sizes/serving quantities
​
Starting at $450
Fun Experiences!
Mobile Cake Bar Experience
A modern, interactive dessert station where guests customize their own personal cake.
Starting at $300 for approx. 50 guests. Additional guests ->$5.00 per person
​
Perfect for late-night desserts or couples looking for something unique!
Treat Tower Experience
A modern, alternative to traditional displays, featuring individual treats stacked into an elegant tower. Guests can choose from a variety of flavors while enjoying a beautiful share-free dessert experience.
Choose from treats like:
-
Cake Cups
-
Cheesecake Cups
-
Donuts
-
Brownies
-
Tiramisu
-
Cinnamon Rolls
$4.00 per guest, 50 guest minimum
Signature Wedding Cupcake Bouquets
Our Signature Wedding Cupcake Bouquets are large-scale edible floral arrangements designed to resemble real wedding florals. Each cupcake is hand-piped with delicate buttercream flowers and arranged into a breathtaking display that doubles as both dessert and décor. Each bouquet is customized to match your wedding color palette, florals, and theme.
Petite Bouquet-24 pieces
Perfect for sweetheart tables, bridal showers, or smaller weddings
Starting at $90
Grand Bouquet-50 pieces
A stunning statement centerpiece for wedding dessert tables
Starting at $180
Classic Bouquet-36 pieces
Our most popular wedding option.
Starting at $135
Luxury Bouquet-75-100 pieces
For couples who want a show-stopping edible floral installation.
Starting at $250-$350
Centerpiece Package
One of the most popular ways couples use cupcake bouquets is as edible table centerpieces.
Instead of traditional florals, guests enjoy a beautiful buttercream flower display that doubles as dessert.
Includes:
• 1 Grand Bouquet (50 cupcakes) for the dessert table
• 5 "mini" Bouquet Centerpieces (8 cupcakes each) for guest tables
• Custom wedding color palette
• Hand-piped buttercream flowers
Starting at $400
**Additional centerpiece bouquets can be added.**
Why Couples Choose MJ's Cookie Jar
Couples love working with MJ's Cookie Jar because we offer:
-
Transparent pricing
-
Flexible dessert options
-
Budget friendly alternatives
-
Premium, from-scratch desserts
-
Creative, modern ideas